FleetGen vs the alternatives
Most brokers stitch together a carrier-vetting tool, a TMS, and a tracking tool. FleetGen replaces the whole stack - verification, fraud prevention, automated onboarding, live ELD tracking, audit-verified proof of delivery, and a full TMS - starting at $299/month, with a free-for-life research tier. Here’s how it compares.
Pick a comparison
FleetGen vs Highway
Highway is the category leader in carrier identity, with the largest verified-carrier network, strong fraud credibility, and deep TMS partnerships. The trade-offs are enterprise, quote-only pricing with no SMB tier, identity-only scope (you still bring your own TMS), and well-documented carrier-side friction over data requests and ELD requirements.
Read comparisoncarrier vetting & onboardingFleetGen vs MyCarrierPortal
MyCarrierPortal (owned by Descartes) is a capable vetting, onboarding, and monitoring tool with one of the largest community fraud-reporting networks in freight. Its trade-offs are cost (a published $515/month starting price), workflow rigidity that brokers describe as "verification loops," and tracking delivered through a MacroPoint integration rather than a direct link to the truck.
Read comparisoncarrier monitoringFleetGen vs Carrier411
Carrier411 is solid, low-cost monitoring with a long-standing FreightGuard community report database. But it is monitoring only: no identity verification, no automated onboarding, no live tracking, and no TMS.
Read comparisoncarrier scoring & vettingFleetGen vs Carrier Assure
Carrier Assure is a useful predictive score: it grades carriers A-F on how well they are likely to perform, recalculated daily from FMCSA and related-entity data. But it is a scoring layer, not an operations platform - no identity verification, no automated onboarding, no live tracking, and no TMS - and it states plainly that its score is "not a guarantee of performance." FleetGen covers the same FMCSA vetting and adds the identity, fraud-prevention, and operations stack brokers need to actually book, track, and prove a load - at $299/month with a free research tier..
Read comparisonWhat to look for in carrier vetting software
The best carrier vetting software does more than pull FMCSA data. As you compare options, weigh these six capabilities - and whether you get them in one platform or have to buy them separately.
Identity & fraud prevention
Does it verify who is actually behind the MC number - government ID, biometric, bank ownership - and flag double-brokering and chameleon carriers before you book?
Automated onboarding
Does it collect W-9s, COIs, and signed agreements automatically, or are you still chasing paperwork by email?
Live ELD tracking
Does it hard-link to the truck’s ELD (un-spoofable), or rely on a phone app or a third-party tracking wrapper?
Operations & TMS
Can you run the load - dispatch, multi-stop routing, invoicing, BOL and rate confirmations - in the same place, or do you need a separate TMS?
Transparent pricing
Is the price published and predictable, or quote-only with per-user, per-load, or per-lookup fees that add up?
Proof of delivery
Does it produce an audit-verified record - IP, user agent, server timestamp, verified signer - you can stand behind in a dispute?
Try FleetGen before you compare
Run unlimited carrier research free for life, then see the full platform on a demo.